Don’t purge those old Christmas decorations quite yet; they might be worth a lot more money than the few cents they would go for at a garage sale! From old-school plastic Santa Clause blow molds to glass figurines of carolers, vintage Christmas decorations are selling online for hundreds of dollars.
‘Tis the season to get merry and bright and, perhaps, a little richer by selling some of these vintage decorations!
1. Toy Soldier Blow Molds: $1,794
Toy Soldier Blow Molds are among the most valuable vintage lawn decorations. Complete and working sets are especially rare, which is why collectors are willing to pay premium prices. A full set can easily cross the $1,000 mark, making these a hidden treasure for many homeowners.
2. The Fisherman Nutcracker From Steinbach: $353
This limited‑edition Steinbach nutcracker is hand‑carved from wood and features a fishing pole and fish accessory. Because Steinbach nutcrackers are known for craftsmanship and low production numbers, collectors actively search for them. Signed versions can sell for even higher prices.
If a person is lucky enough to have a signed nutcracker, it can go for even more!
3.Pink Evergleam Aluminum Christmas Tree: $5,000
Dating back to the 1960s, the Pink Evergleam Aluminum Christmas Tree is one of the most iconic holiday decorations ever made. Standing six feet tall with 55 pink glittering branches, it represents mid‑century holiday style and is considered a crown jewel among collectors.
4. Santa And Mrs. Claus Blow Molds: $250
Produced by General Foam and Don Featherstone, these 39‑inch illuminated blow molds are classic outdoor Christmas decorations. Their nostalgic appeal and working lights make them a consistent seller every holiday season.
If they’re gathering dust and not being used, though, there are sets listed for $250.
5. Spun Cotton Heubach Boy Christmas Ornament: $420
This antique ornament is made from hand‑spun cotton, which makes it extremely delicate and rare. Because few have survived in good condition, collectors are willing to pay hundreds of dollars for authentic Heubach ornaments.
This handspun cotton antique ornament is listed for $420
6. Vintage Victorian Angel Tree Topper: $859
Victorian angel tree toppers are prized for their materials and craftsmanship. Made using wax, glass beads, and silk, this angel represents 19th‑century Christmas traditions and is one of the most expensive tree toppers available today
On , this angel is listed for a whopping $895.
7. Paper Mache Mr. and Mrs. Claus Circa 1940: $525
This handmade paper mache Santa and Mrs. Claus set dates back to the 1940s. Standing 18 inches tall, the set is highly collectible due to its age, fragility, and limited availability.
Handmade, this set is an antique from the 1940s, stands 18-inches tall, and is a Christmas decoration collector’s dream find.
8. Ceramic Volcano Christmas Tree: $600
A popular décor item from the 1970s, this white ceramic tree features dove‑shaped lights that glow orange when illuminated. Although styles have changed, collector demand has kept its value high.
A popular décor item from the 1970s, this white ceramic tree features dove‑shaped lights that glow orange when illuminated. Although styles have changed, collector demand has kept its value high.
9. Ceramic Letter To Santa: $1,200
Goebel Hummel figurines are known worldwide for their quality and rarity. The “Letter to Santa” piece, showing a schoolgirl mailing her letter, is one of the most desirable models and commands four‑figure prices.
The figurine depicts a schoolgirl putting a letter into a mailbox with her wooden sleigh underneath her.
10. Bradford Celestial Star Tree Topper: $200 – $600
Manufactured in the 1950s, this rotating star features a stained‑glass style design that creates a light‑show effect. Its mechanical movement and vintage appeal make it a standout tree topper.
On eBay. this item is listed anywhere between $200 and $600.
11. Christmas Shopper Figurine Holding A Wreath: $135
Made by Relco in the 1950s, this figurine shows a festive shopper holding a green wreath. It is popular among collectors looking to complete matching Christmas figurine sets.
Wearing a cute Christmas dress and bonnet adorned with holy and holding a holiday wreath, this figurine is on Etsy and selling for $135, with buyers leaving reviews such as, “Awesome Relco Christmas girl! This one completed my set.”
12. Christmas Boy Girl Santa Vintage Planter: $239
This small ceramic planter from 1950s Japan is both decorative and functional. Its compact size and charming design make it a sought‑after collectible on platforms like Etsy.
On Etsy, this planter is listed for $239.
13. Department 56 Gingerbread House: $175
This ceramic gingerbread house is part of the popular Department 56 collection. Instead of building edible houses, collectors prefer this long‑lasting decorative alternative.
On eBay, this particular gingerbread house is listed for $175.
14. Dickens Village Mill: $1,250
Inspired by Charles Dickens’ writings, this Department 56 mill is extremely rare, with only 2,500 units ever produced. Scarcity alone makes it one of the most valuable village pieces.
Due to the minimal number of Village Mills out in the world, this piece can sell for up to $1,250.
15. Christmas Vacation Griswold Holiday House: $340
Based on the iconic movie National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, this ceramic house replica is a fan favorite. Movie nostalgia plays a major role in its resale value.
On eBay, the Department 56 National Lampoon Christmas Vacation Griswold Holiday House is listed for $340.
16.A Christmas Story Town Tree: $625
Produced by Lenox, this porcelain nativity set features beloved Peanuts characters. Its gentle colors and character appeal make it popular with both Peanuts fans and holiday collectors.
17. The Christmas Pageant Peanuts Nativity Scene: $179.95
Produced by Lenox, this porcelain nativity set features beloved Peanuts characters. Its gentle colors and character appeal make it popular with both Peanuts fans and holiday collectors.
Made of porcelain and beautifully painted with mute colors, a brand-new Peanuts Nativity scene can go for as much as $179.95.
18. Waving Santa And Reindeer Blow Mold: $2,400
Made by Empire in 1970, this blow mold was sold for only one season. Santa’s waving motion sets it apart, making it one of the rarest and most valuable blow molds ever produced.
19. Peanuts Snoopy Santa Christmas Blow Mold: $299
This three‑foot‑tall Snoopy blow mold shows the character dressed as Santa and holding a green sack. Its timeless design ensures strong demand year after year.
On eBay, this particular blow mold is listed for $299.
20. Christmas Shopper Girl: $100 – $250
This elegant glass figurine features a girl in a red dress holding a present. Norcrest figurines are well‑known among collectors for their fine detailing.
This is one of those items collectors would be eager to get their hands on, especially if it is not being displayed! On eBay, figurines from the Norcrest Shopper Girl collection as listed anywhere between $100 and $250.
21. Sylvania Santa’s Train: $234
A nostalgic lawn decoration from the 1990s, Santa’s Train features rotating lights that simulate motion. Its rarity today has driven up collector interest.
22. Department 56 Todd and Margo Jogging: $850
These figurines from Christmas Vacation are highly collectible, even without the full village set. Fans of the movie actively seek them out.
Even without the house and other figurines from the set, Todd and Margo are still listed for $850.
23. Solid Brass Deer: $1,150
Solid brass deer are timeless holiday decorations. Their durability and elegant design ensure long‑term value, with complete sets commanding over $1,000 on resale markets.
A set of two in pristine condition is listed on eBay for $1,150.
24.Life-Size Blow Mold Nativity Scene: $3,000
Life-size blow mold nativity scenes are among the most impressive outdoor Christmas decorations. This 11-piece set by General Foam features figures as tall as five feet. After the company shut down in 2018, demand surged, pushing prices into the thousands.
Since the company went out of business in 2018, their blow molds have skyrocketed in price. This entire 11-piece set created in 1995, for example, is listed for $3,000 on eBay.
25. “A Great Grinchy Trick” Figurine: $1,200
Created by Department 56, this Grinch figurine is a rare collector’s piece. Featuring Dr. Seuss’ iconic character mid-mischief, it has become one of the most valuable Grinch-themed decorations available.
On eBay, this figurine is listed for $1,200.
26. Brass Sleigh Bells On A Leather Strap: $249
Mounted on a vintage 78-inch leather strap, these 30 working brass sleigh bells capture the true spirit of Christmas. Authenticity and sound quality make them highly collectible.
Instead of allowing them to collect dust in the basement or attic, this eBay seller listed these vintage sleigh bells for a whopping $249.
27. Christmas Vacation Boss Shirley’s House: $2,799
This Platinum Key Special Edition from Department 56 is a miniature replica of the mansion from National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation. With working lights and limited production, it is one of the most expensive movie-themed village pieces.
The house is a mini replica of the Shirley’s mansion, complete with working holiday lights. On eBay, this Department 56 piece sold for just under $3,000.
28. Bethlehem Village: $375
This 19-piece hand-painted nativity set by Grandeur Noel includes illuminated buildings, trees, and figures. Its size and detail make it a striking holiday display..
On eBay, a 19-piece set is listed for $375.
29. Atlantic Mold Ceramic Christmas Tree: $688
Produced in the 1970s, this tall ceramic tree features unique bow-shaped lights and a large star topper. Atlantic Mold trees remain extremely popular among collectors.
This vintage piece is not cheap, either, with people selling theirs for up to $688.
30. Vintage Original 18K Gold Natural Diamond Brooch – $8,899
This one-of-a-kind Christmas brooch is crafted from white and yellow gold and set with natural diamonds. Its luxury materials place it among the most valuable Christmas collectibles ever listed.
And those who somehow come across one in the wild should be aware that a seller in Turkey is asking for $8,899 for this one on eBay.
31. Deck The Halls Charlie Brown Peanuts Gang Magic Ornament – $299
This Hallmark Keepsake ornament features the Peanuts gang gathered around a Christmas tree. Despite being from 2006, its popularity and limited availability have driven prices upward.
Because those who find this and list it for about $300 on eBay will find they’re not the only ones.
32. French Kugel Ball Cathedral Mirror Mosaic Ornament – $4,850
French Kugel ornaments are extremely rare. Even with visible wear and rust, this cathedral-style mosaic ornament commands a high price due to its historical significance.
For instance, this one is not in perfect condition and shows signs of rust, but is still apparently worth $4,850 on eBay.
33. Snowman Resin Ornament – $276
A nostalgic snowman design once commonly seen during childhood holidays now sells for hundreds due to scarcity and collector demand.
Indeed, Amazon sellers are listing this friendly fellow for up to $276 a pop.
34. Mechanical Santa Clause Gimbels Store Display – $2,999
This 1950s mechanical Santa display from the now-defunct Gimbels department store remains valuable even in worn condition. Better-preserved versions can sell for even more.
So one can only imagine how much they’d be able to get for a more well-preserved version of this item.
35.Christmas Vintage Red Trucks – $136
Small wooden and metal red trucks are beloved symbols of Christmas décor. Though modestly priced, they are still worth far more than their original cost.
While $100 to $150 may not be a life-changing amount of money for a lot of people, it’s certainly more than this would have cost back in the day.
36. Vintage Animated Coca-Cola Santa Claus & Dog – $225
Coca-Cola’s influence on Santa imagery made these branded decorations iconic. Animated versions featuring Santa and his dog are especially collectible.
And those who have both this Santa figure and his little dog may find themselves netting up to $225 if they resell the whole set.
37. Vintage “Santa’s List Christmas Decorative” Plate – $1,499
Commemorative plates were once common holiday décor. Today, surviving vintage examples like this one can sell for well over $1,000.
But for those who still have them lying around, it’s not impossible that they’re now worth some serious money. After all, this “Santa’s List” plate is now being listed on eBay for $1,499.
38.Rushton Rubber Face Santa Claus – $200
Produced in the 1950s, Rushton Santas are instantly recognizable by their rubber faces. Sets with musical features increase their value.
Based on their condition and the fact that one of them has music-playing capabilities, these two are apparently worth about $200 when sold together.
39.Hand-Painted Glass Mushroom Ornaments – $98
Made in the Czech Republic, these delicate ornaments are sold in sets. Larger quantities increase resale value significantly.
For instance, the 12 shown here are worth about $98, while a set of six is worth about $50, and a set of 24 is listed for $168. So the more of them a person can get together at once, the bigger their payout.
40.Alfco Choir Boys Blow Molds – $999
These 1950s blow molds may look unusual by today’s standards, but their rarity and vintage appeal make them worth nearly $1,000.
But while these choir boys may look a little creepier than they would have in the ’50s, that doesn’t make them any less valuable. Because modern eBay listings suggest they’re worth about $1,000.
41.Old Piglet Christmas Ornament – $899
These 1950s blow molds may look unusual by today’s standards, but their rarity and vintage appeal make them worth nearly $1,000.
After all, it’s listed at nearly $900, which makes it hard not to wonder what a mint-condition piglet would go for.
42.Fontanini Nativity Set With Lighted Stable – $875
This detailed nativity set includes multiple figures and accessories, along with a lighted stable. Completeness greatly boosts its value.
Even if the stable didn’t come with lights, it’s hard to imagine this vintage set selling for less than the listed $875.
43. Antique Klosterarbeit – $850
Handcrafted in monasteries around the turn of the 20th century, these decorations are prized for their natural materials and age.
Although some of the small silver balls on it have since broken, even a slightly damaged version of these antiques could potentially net someone up to $850.
44.Large Figural Santa Claus Christmas Light – $4,500
Manufactured in Dresden in 1927, this Santa lamp is both decorative and historical. Its age and size justify its premium price.
At first glance, that green patch to the side may look like some discoloration, but the texture indicates that Santa is supposed to be holding a tree. So, the seller is unlikely to budge on their $4,500 asking price.
45.1991 Swarovski Annual Ornament – $4,000
Although relatively modern, this Swarovski ornament’s exclusivity and pristine condition make it exceptionally valuable.
Indeed, that must be the case for this crystal clear and well-preserved Swarovski ornament because it would otherwise be outrageous to expect anyone to pay $4,000 for it.
46.Erzgebirge German Bell Angel – $3,299
If this angel and her unusual whirligig seem like bizarre Christmas decorations, that’s likely due to the fact that they came from an era when Christmas was celebrated radically differently than now.
Designed to spin using candle heat, this early 1900s German angel features a mechanical bell-ringing system and strong collector appeal.
47. Antique Rocking Santa on Reindeer – $3,200
Over a century old, this German-made rocking Santa display reflects master craftsmanship and durability.
And while it’s not exactly impossible to believe that this is over 100 years old, the $3,200 price point is justified by how clearly it was built to last.
48.Russian Christmas Handmade Santa – $2,995
Created in the 1990s, this handmade Russian Santa has become rare over time, increasing its resale value dramatically.
As such, despite being made in the ’90s, this Russian Santa figurine can apparently fetch $2,995. It certainly makes one wonder what that piece that inspired it would cost nowadays.
49.Blow Mold Nativity Set – $2,950
AThis oversized blow mold nativity set features 36-inch tall figures, setting it apart from standard versions and increasing its desirability.
To provide a sense of scale, the standing human figures in this $2,950 set are about 36 inches tall.
50.Dresden Santa Book Cover – $2,500
Made in 1876, this decorative book cover shows an early depiction of Santa before the modern jolly image became popular, making it a historically significant collectible.
And the biggest piece of evidence for this timeline is Santa’s relatively slim figure. After all, it wasn’t so long before this cover was made that he was described as the jolly, rotund elf everyone knows today for the first time.